1st Test Preview: South Africa vs Australia, Cape Town

I am not the first, and definitely will not be the last to bemoan the ridiculous nature of this series taking the guise of a 2 Test match up between heated rivals. This is due to the preference being shown to money cricket (T20), rather than respect being shown to the true form of the game in Tests. Sadly it is a cynical World we live in, and rather than be frustrated by the obvious grab for T20 cash. That so occupies World cricket in this age.

1st Test Preview: South Africa vs Australia, Cape Town

1st Test Preview: South Africa vs Australia, Cape Town

Let us instead find a smile by dissecting what should be a cracker of a series, starting with this first Test.

Likely Teams

South Africa

The South Africans have a very solid outfit, that has been made even steelier at the top of the order with the re inclusion of a fabulous player in Jacques Rudolph. So it takes away one of the weaknesses in the line up in the opening partner for Captain Graeme Smith. The only real conjecture about the team is whether Ashwell Prince or JP Duminy gets the nod to bat at 6.

Both have been similar in their struggles in the Test arena with Prince averaging 32.23 in his last 17 innings and Duminy averaging 18.81 in his last 17 innings. I would select Duminy, not only because I think he is a fine young player, but also on a pitch that might turn. His very underrated off spin might be a decisive factor in the Test. So, this would be my Team.

Smith, Rudolph, Amla, Kallis, DeVilliers, Duminy, Boucher, Steyn, Morkel, Tahir, Tsotsobe.


The Australians have a pretty settled line up like the South Africans. The only real question mark will be over who gets the third seamers role with it being between Peter Siddle and Trent Copeland. I think this is a no brainer with Siddle being a more complete bowler than Copeland. In the threat he poses with new or old ball, whereas Copeland once the shine goes off the ball his threat goes as well with him becoming very much military medium. Duly leaving the line up like this.

Watson, Hughes, Marsh, Clarke, Ponting, Hussey, Haddin, Johnson, Siddle, Harris, Lyon.

Who Wins, and Why?

The more I pontificate about this series, the more I come to the conclusion that this game, and ultimately the series will be decided by which Team bats the best.

I say this because of the support to the bowlers that South Africa conditions usually give, and then the potential threat of the individual bowlers. Starting with South Africa, in Dale Steyn you have a bowler that is comparable to any bowler in the history of the game. Then his able offsider Morne Morkel gets better by the year as his average of 25.21 in his last 12 Tests show.

Then you have the evergreen Jacques Kallis, and two bowlers in the left arm swing bowler Lonwabo Tsotsobe and Imran Tahir that could make an already very fine bowling attack into one that is frighteningly good.

In particular Tahir, by the fact that the Aussies haven’t seen much of him could be a real success with his leg spin.

Though, Australia haven’t got a bowler of the threat and presence of Dale Steyn. In Ryan Harris, they have a bowler that I anticipate will shake the South African batting line up to its very foundations.

The South African conditions will be like a bed for Harris to lie in, and with his pace, swing and how much he gets the ball to talk off the wicket. Expect him to be a wrecking ball all series.

Also, Peter Siddle in these conditions is going to be one very hard customer to deal with for the South African batsmen. If Mitchell Johnson can replicate any of his exploits from a few years back in South Africa then the Aussies will be well placed for an upset win.

Though having any faith in Mitchell Johnson to be anything but a sequel of Steve Harmison in regards to erraticness and frustration is never a good idea.

Completing Australia’s attack nicely is the threat of Shane Watson, and his lethal reverse swing. He might be an opening batsman at present, but has all the ability to be a very fine opening bowler.

So in the face of potentially great bowling, which Teams batting has the best chance of handling the assault the best and posting respectable scores?

I think this is pretty easy to discern with names of real quality in the South African line up, such as Hashim Amla, Jacques Kallis, AB DeVilliers and Graeme Smith. In comparison with Australia’s Swiss like cheese batting line up that has many holes.

Only Mike Hussey has been a thing of certainty in terms of performance in the Aussie line up with Michael Clarke showing signs of a renaissance in Sri Lanka after near on two years of struggle.

Shaun Marsh looked very assured at number 3 in Sri Lanka, and I do not want to diminish in any way his very fine performance there. It must be said that batting on Sri Lankan roads against their bowling attack of pie chuckers is a bit different to facing Steyn and compnay in South Africa.

The rest of the batting has major concerns.

Starting with Phil Hughes who saved his career with a century in the 3rd Test in Sri Lanka on a real road, but has a technique as loose as a weightwatchers girdle. That will duly be victimised in South Africa.

Then the vastly diminished form of Shane Watson at the top, and the once great Ricky Ponting.

Watson averaging 38.10 in his last 29 innings and 24.28 in 2011.

Ponting averaging 34.70 in his last 27 innings and 31.00 in 2011.

Both are fine players, and indeed Ponting a great of the game, but you would have to be an eternal optimist to view them refinding form on this tour.


I can see Australia giving some real cheek with their bowling.

Though I can not see any possible way that the Australian batting can stand up against a very formidable and varied attack. Whereas I can see the South African batting being accomplished enough to contend with the Aussie attack.

So barring rain, South Africa should win easily.

Tags: , , , , ,

Tim Holt


Hi All, I’m an old gent having been born in 1953 in Derry, Nth Ireland. I learnt my love for cricket during my time in South Africa in between 1964-66. My hero as you can see by my profile picture is 'Chandra'! I am a qualified journalist having worked in Radio and papers across the Globe. Though I’m currently a teacher, who is on extended medical leave due to my heart not agreeing with the Irish past time of drinking copious amounts of Whisky! I have many tales to tell in regards to a lot of sports having played both Football and Cricket professionally. I hope you enjoy a few I share with you! Regards and Peace to All Tim


CEAT signs endorsement deal with Harmanpreet Kaur

CEAT signs endorsement deal with Harmanpreet Kaur

Posted by: Vikram Kamboj on January 22nd, 2018

CEAT Ltd. today announced its association with one of most prolific all-rounders in women’s cricketer Harmanpreet Kaur, for a period of 2 years. The bat endor ..


FFCI Football Monthly Achievement Awards

FFCI Football Monthly Achievement Awards

Posted by: Vikram Kamboj on January 10th, 2018

Federation of Football Coaches in India (FFCI), an Organization formed in 2011 and approved by the All India Football Federation (AIFF ) organized its Monthly A ..


Tennys Sandgren thrashes out Wawrinka in the second round of the Australian Open

Tennys Sandgren thrashes out Wawrinka in the second round of the Australian Open

Posted by: Mahalakshmi Murali on January 19th, 2018

The World Number 9, Switzerland’s three-time Grand Slam champion, Stanislas Wawrinka ends his journey in Melbourne in the second round of the 2018 Australian ..


Life Lessons learned from Sports & Fitness #TOSBDay

Life Lessons learned from Sports & Fitness #TOSBDay

Posted by: Vikram Kamboj on September 26th, 2016

Held on Sept 1st, The Outstanding Speakers’ Bureau (TOSB) Twinterview consisted of sports panelists such as Mark Gallagher (Public Speaker on F1 race), Shayam ..


Rajasthan Rumble – Vijender Singh’s double-title defense against Ghana’s Ernest Amuzu

Rajasthan Rumble – Vijender Singh’s double-title defense against Ghana’s Ernest Amuzu

Posted by: Vikram Kamboj on December 22nd, 2017

Undefeated Indian knockout king, Vijender Singh is set to defend his WBO Oriental and Asia Pacific Super middleweight titles against African Champion Ernest Amu ..

Other Sports

Play on and let the experts handle the legalities

Play on and let the experts handle the legalities

Posted by: Vikram Kamboj on January 23rd, 2018

Sportspersons lifts the spirits of the society. They are the icons who amaze the kids and inspire the adults. They are the people who accomplish the impossible ..

One stop guide to all the latest sports news, reviews, opinions, fixtures and live scores from India and around the world.

Copyright © 2017 | The Sports Mirror