Look beyond Sachin Tendulkar for criticism and axing to poor team performance

Too much limelight on Sachin has benefits too, like how now its shielding poor performance of other players in the team from most eyes.

Sachin needs match practice prior to each series due to the long breaks he is taking.

Not surprisingly, last three days saw flood of articles on Sachin Tendulkar in both paper and digital media, which never misses an opportunity to either hype or criticize his performance over other players and the team. Getting out bowled, that too middle stump off the ground, three times on a row and poor numbers in the entire series against not so good test team like New Zealand surely invites lots of scrutiny and also adds fuel to this growing poor habit of determining once retirement based on age alone. But the way all going bonkers like Sachin alone underperformed and deserved to be axed is just not good and constructive criticism.

Sure, Sachin performance was way below his own standards but when others in team fared even poorer then him, how come he only deserves the axe? Table below clearly shows Sachin despite under performing fared better than Sehwag, Gambhir and retired Laxman. And we don’t even need to talk about Suresh Raina (four ducks in 11 innings) actually.

Indian players batting performance from England series last year to recently concluded New Zealand series:

Player Mat Inns NO Runs HS Ave BF SR 100 50 0
R Dravid 11 21 2 974 146* 51.26 2133 45.66 4 3 0
SR Tendulkar 13 24 0 841 94 35.04 1581 53.19 0 6 0
MS Dhoni 12 22 4 670 144 37.22 1126 59.50 1 5 2
VVS Laxman 11 21 2 635 176* 33.42 1266 50.15 1 4 1
V Kohli 7 13 1 627 116 52.25 1186 52.86 2 5 1
V Sehwag 11 20 0 612 67 30.60 715 85.59 0 5 3
G Gambhir 12 22 0 536 83 24.36 1134 47.26 0 3 1
R Ashwin 8 12 3 353 103 39.22 482 73.23 1 1 1
SK Raina 6 11 0 163 78 14.81 365 44.65 0 2 4

(*stats from www.cricinfo.com)

If we remove runs from home test series against NZ and WI, then in terms of average, everyone except Kohli (37.50) and Dravid (46.78) falls below Sachin (35.00), and in terms of runs, Sachin (560) is second only to Dravid (665). With Rahul Dravid being India’s best test batsmen in last year retired, Sachin is surely the second best if not best in the current test line-up. Even in terms of fitness, Sachin at 39 is still going strong. I would say, he is better than Sehwag and on par with Gambhir. So, if you are talking about dropping someone from the test team, then better first consider Sehwag, Gambhir and Raina before Sachin.

Actually, his second high percentage of dismissal type is bowled (17%) after caught (60.6%).

I am not so sure why so much fuss about Sachin getting bowled. If you take his track record, he is always been troubled by the incoming deliveries which resulted in either LBW or bowled often if dismissed. Moreover, I believe Sachin reason for tentativeness against NZ was due to lack of match practice. He didn’t played a match in-between IPL and NZ test series, i.e. nearly three months. Doesn’t matter how much experienced you are and hours spent on nets, batting on the match is very different. It is evident that in second innings of second test after spending some quality time in crease, Sachin looked in better rhythm. He was making long forward strides, punching the ball off the back foot and leaning well to cover drive the ball. So, what we need to make sure before England test series is Sachin having good match practice and someone like Sunil Gavaskar walking up to tell him, “Champ, its that time you must look to play more straight and not across to midwicket.”

Although he will play in Champions League T20 for Mumbai Indians, we need him to play in one or two Ranji matches prior to the series start and problem solved. About retirement, it is his personal decision. As i said here, selectors can drop him if he don’t perform or not physically fit or not needed by team anymore. Sachin for his quality will surely make runs against any team and at any conditions.

Indian test team got far bigger problem to worry then Sachin at present. Bowling despite getting 40 wickets in the series against New Zealand wasn’t really impressive, rather raised more concerns. If at all want to debate and raise a valid concern, then first do it on bowling (both spin and seam), Gambhir and Sehwag. As a team, India moved away from living in shadows of Sachin long ago. So, you too better start moving.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,



T20 Global League: KXIP’s Preity Zinta to own Stellenbosch franchise

T20 Global League: KXIP’s Preity Zinta to own Stellenbosch franchise

Posted by: Vikram Kamboj on September 8th, 2017

From Punjab to Paarl – Bollywood actress and IPL Kings XI Punjab team co-owner, PreityZinta, has been confirmed as the owner of the Stellenbosch franchise ..


Delhi Dynamos sign striker Kalu Uche

Delhi Dynamos sign striker Kalu Uche

Posted by: Vikram Kamboj on September 7th, 2017

Indian Super League outfit Delhi Dynamos have roped in Nigerian forward Kalu Uche as their fourth foreign signing for the upcoming edition of the Indian Super L ..


Rafael Nadal vs Stan Wawrinka: French Open Men’s Final 2017 – Preview

Rafael Nadal vs Stan Wawrinka: French Open Men’s Final 2017 – Preview

Posted by: Atish Home Chowdhury on June 11th, 2017

The stage is set for the mouth-watering and nail-biting clash of the two Tennis stalwarts of the current era; Rafael Nadal and Stan Wawrinka. This will be the u ..


Life Lessons learned from Sports & Fitness #TOSBDay

Life Lessons learned from Sports & Fitness #TOSBDay

Posted by: Vikram Kamboj on September 26th, 2016

Held on Sept 1st, The Outstanding Speakers’ Bureau (TOSB) Twinterview consisted of sports panelists such as Mark Gallagher (Public Speaker on F1 race), Shayam ..


Boxing Federation of India successfully concludes AIBA Course and Examination

Boxing Federation of India successfully concludes AIBA Course and Examination

Posted by: Vikram Kamboj on February 24th, 2017

Rohtak, February 24, 2016: In continuation to produce the AIBA certified Coaches, Referees and Judges; Boxing Federation of India successfully organised the AIB ..

Other Sports

Indian athletes begin impressively at 22nd Asian Athletics Championships

Indian athletes begin impressively at 22nd Asian Athletics Championships

Posted by: Vikram Kamboj on July 6th, 2017

Indian interests on the opening day of the 22nd Asian Athletics Championships were high with national record holder Muhammed Anas easing into the semi-finals of ..

One stop guide to all the latest sports news, reviews, opinions, fixtures and live scores from India and around the world.

Copyright © 2017 | The Sports Mirror